Best home warranty companies

There is no single best home warranty — there is a best fit for your home’s age, your systems, and how many claims you expect. These are six established companies, organised by the job each one does best.

Context: two surveys, two averages — use the range. NerdWallet (March 2026) puts the average plan at $73 a month ($876 a year) with an average service fee of $108.45; This Old House (November 2026, 4,000+ quotes from 13 companies) puts the average at $56 a month ($672 a year) with service fees typically $75–$125. Honest framing: roughly $560–$985 a year for the plan, plus $75–$125 per claim. A warranty is a service contract, not home insurance — it covers systems and appliances wearing out, not the structure, and it does not cover fire or flood.

CompanyBest forOur ratingHow it sellsWhy it is on this list
American Home ShieldThe company that pioneered the industryNot yet rated — see methodologyHome warranty; service fee $100–$125 per claim; monthly $36–$100 in the This Old House survey.Founded 1971, Memphis, Tennessee. Subsidiary of Frontdoor, Inc.; described as the company that pioneered the home-warranty industry. Covers 48 states.
Choice Home WarrantyA fixed $100 service fee, no choices to makeNot yet rated — see methodologyHome warranty; fixed $100 service fee (no choice of fee level); monthly $60–$68 in the This Old House survey.Founded 2008, Edison, New Jersey. Named to the Inc. 5000 for five consecutive years. Covers 49 states.
First American Home WarrantyThe oldest name in the groupNot yet rated — see methodologyHome warranty; service fee $100–$125; monthly $77–$130 in the This Old House survey.Founded 1984; part of the First American family of companies, heritage back to 1889. Headquartered in California.
Cinch Home ServicesThree plans and a choice of service feeNot yet rated — see methodologyHome warranty; three plans — Appliances, Built-in Systems, Complete Home; customer chooses service fee $100, $125, or $150.Founded 1979, Boca Raton, Florida. Also noted for a 180-day workmanship promise.
Select Home WarrantyThree tiers with a $75 flat service feeNot yet rated — see methodologyHome warranty; three tiers — Bronze, Gold, Platinum (appliances / systems / combo); $75 flat service fee.Founded 2012, Mahwah, New Jersey. Operates in 47 states; contracts transferable and renewable.
AFC Home WarrantyThe lowest surveyed costs, with electronics coverageNot yet rated — see methodologyHome warranty; lowest overall costs in the This Old House survey ($44–$82/month, $528–$984/year; service fee $75–$125).Founded 2009. Diamond Plan includes specialised electronics coverage few rivals offer. Available in 48 states, excluding California and Hawaii.

How we ranked these companies

Rankings here are “best for” fits, not a single overall winner. Inputs, per our methodology: the 5-point evidence check (identity and licensing, pricing transparency, complaint patterns, refund terms, independent evidence), plan structure (systems, appliances, or both), service-fee terms, state availability, and documented features such as tier structures and workmanship promises. Commercial relationships are never an input. Every company below still shows “Not yet rated”: we publish a numeric score only with its inputs visible on the page, and that scoring has not shipped for any company yet.

What to do next

What will your plan really cost per year?

Our home warranty cost estimator adds the plan price to the service fees on your expected number of claims.

Warranty vs. insurance — do not confuse them

Home insurance rebuilds the house; a warranty repairs the things inside it wearing out. See our home insurance hub.

Sources for company facts on this page (checked November 2026): American Home Shield — founded 1971, Memphis, Tennessee; subsidiary of Frontdoor, Inc.; service fee $100–$125, 48 states (This Old House, Nov 2026). Choice Home Warranty — founded 2008, Edison, New Jersey; fixed $100 service fee, 49 states; Inc. 5000 five consecutive years (company site, 2016; This Old House, Nov 2026). First American Home Warranty — founded 1984 (company site); First American family heritage back to 1889; service fee $100–$125 (This Old House, Nov 2026). Headquarters city is not published here: sources conflict (West Hills, Santa Ana, Santa Rosa, Van Nuys, California). Cinch Home Services — founded 1979, Boca Raton, Florida (BBB Business Profile); three plans; service fee $100/$125/$150 (CrunchWize, July 2026; DoorLoop, June 2026). Select Home Warranty — founded 2012, Mahwah, New Jersey (ConsumerAffairs, Nov 10, 2026); three tiers; $75 flat service fee; 47 states. AFC Home Warranty — founded 2009; Diamond Plan electronics coverage; lowest surveyed costs $44–$82/month (This Old House, Nov 2026); 48 states excluding CA and HI (Today’s Homeowner, 2026). Headquarters city is not published here: sources conflict (Marietta, Georgia vs. Edison, New Jersey). Market data: NerdWallet (Mar 2, 2026); This Old House (Nov 2026).